Forum Sahabat Silat

English Version => Pencak Silat General Forum => Topic started by: Hammock Rider on 07/04/2011 22:19

Title: Comparing Silat to Wing Chun?
Post by: Hammock Rider on 07/04/2011 22:19

Hello Everyone,
  I was wondering if any style of silat uses a wooden dummy as is used in Wing Chun? Also does Silat contain anything like the Wing Chun chi sau?  These things have attracted me to Wing Chun and I was wondering if they exist in any style of Silat as well.
Thanks.

Title: Re: Comparing Silat to Wing Chun?
Post by: f4iz on 07/04/2011 23:16

Hello Hammock,
Did you start going to the Silat class you mentioned a while back ?
To be honest with you, I don't know if Indonesian Silat systems formally use a Mook Jong (Wooden Dummy) as part of their practice. I know a Malaysian Silat System called Gayang Lima (G5) utilizes their version of Wooden Dummy.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XrmljuaerKo (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XrmljuaerKo)
I've also seen some Silat practitioners as individuals incorporating the wooden dummy to practice their techniques.  I think the wooden dummy was originally used to substitute a training partner for practicing striking and blocking ?
When you say similar to Chi Sau, you mean to develop sensitivies and reflex ? Many silat systems have their own drills and training to develop sensitivities and reflex.
Regards,

Title: Re: Comparing Silat to Wing Chun?
Post by: Hammock Rider on 08/04/2011 05:22

Hello godam,
   Sensitivity and reflex is exactly what I was getting at. I would like to improve those attributes in myself. I have seen some video clips of silat practitioners and some seem to flow around their opponent, which is also impressive. Thanks for your response.

  I haven't attended a class yet because my doc says to give my knee a few moew weeks to heal. But I am looking forward to it.

Title: Re: Comparing Silat to Wing Chun?
Post by: ogebang on 08/04/2011 10:34

Hallo Mas Hammock Rider...

Many silat systems are similar to Wing Chun..why don't you check Cimande style out...

Title: Re: Comparing Silat to Wing Chun?
Post by: santri kinasih on 08/04/2011 13:57

Hammock Rider,

if you had the chance to go to Indonesia, there a number of silat styles can improve your senses and reflex...Check out the preview at www. videosilat.com..You don't even have to worry about your knees if you want to start training. you can train while you are sitting..:D

Title: Re: Comparing Silat to Wing Chun?
Post by: Qeyz on 13/10/2011 12:31

You can even lear silat while eating also

Title: Re: Comparing Silat to Wing Chun?
Post by: hahaha.. on 15/10/2011 06:29

it's a bird...it's a plane...it's superman!!

ok jack rider, alright well when you get back from the ‘knee land’ can you let us know if your doc have a sameness decent ‘massage oil’ with silat ?

come on ladies and gent, we don’t  need talk to someone say, hey you! yeah you, want to know something? i knew what you lookslike, can you make me starts feeling good?

come on ladies an gent, we are not sleazy salesmanship..

he will come if he wanted,
and for now, he just needs more vodka gallons for his DUMMY-STANDARDS..

thanks.

Title: Re: Comparing Silat to Wing Chun?
Post by: harunhdr on 23/10/2011 16:12

About the similarity Chi sau in silat, we can see this methode in Cikalong style. I ever see a picture that a teacher in Cikalong use the technique that has a kind of chi sau from master Yip Man. Maybe , masters from Cikalong can explain it.